The place to go for vinyl. The staff, selection, prices are all great. Two easy locations. What one store doesn't have the other store one has. A place for all ages. Bill Dee
Great browsing. I always come away with something I didn’t know I was looking for. Richard Riis
floor to ceiling! huge selection of vinyl, cd's, DVD's. great store with friendly staff Kerry Cleary
Great people, great store! Love thumbing through the used CDs and vinyl lps. Have seen some awesome concerts courtesy of these guys. They share their perks with their customers. If you don't patronize one of their two great locations, you SHOULD! There aren't too many old school record stores around! Victoria Bick Bixby Nuttall
What's not to like about Mr. Cheapos ? Endless racks of new and used Vinyl Lp's, Cd's and Dvd's at great prices combined with a knowledgeable, personable staff . Very supportive of the local music scene partnering with local music venues including the Paramount ,The Space and the Westbury Music Fair in ticket giveaways of which i have been a happy recipient of on more than one occasion.There is a reason they have been a mainstay in commack for over 30 plus years as they satisfy all your music needs . 5 stars ★★★★★ Alan Banville
Unbelievable little shop, huge variety of used vinyl and prices a fraction of other record shops closer to the city. Can't wait to go to the Commack store! George Gregoriou
I frequent both locations. More so, the Commack store. Both stores are shrines to the the world of recorded music. These are real record stores, with a clear emphasis on a passion for music and a desire to share the love of music with others, at reasonable and often ludicrously cheap prices! The selection ranges from old to new, including a decent amount of obscure stuff, and covers many different genres. Beyond records and cds, they also sell posters (at low prices), dvds and video tapes, video games, old music magazines and books, and plenty of brand new music in addition to all the used stuff. The staff have always been low pressure and friendly and patient, and reasonable with returns and exchanges. Mr. Cheapo's allows the customer to fully embrace the classic paradigm of the record store shopping and browsing experience. Jason Berk July 2016
My home away from home.. Hassle free browsing.. Just a great store!
Shorty Le Felin Ciboulettes Dec.10 2015
Been coming here for years and I always love browsing there enormous selection of vinyls!
The ONLY place to buy used cds videos books & games. Been shopping here since the 80s.
David S. Kapp
Simply the best place for selection, service and most of all great people....Bob Nizza October 14
Analog Heaven Prices aren't bad at all. #lp #record #longplay #vinyl John Brian Silverio May 24 2014
Just in there today, picked up some amazing finds! So happy my girlfriend found this place! i now have a regular record store to shop at!!! Alex Matthew February 16 2014
My daily drive by or patronage at mr cheapos is one that I liken to direct contact and sad reminiscence of a species entering the latter stages of extinction by the hands of corporate iTunes and pirate media wrath. It's a reminder of times that passed less than a decade ago before The Machine as I call it began to make marketing a tangible album more difficult and begun to bring all the impishly mediocre and downright terrible "artists" to the mainstream that our ears are blessed with today, and left the hard working and talented musicians behind to eat the scraps. Mr cheapos is one of the last, and endured even after tower records and the legendary slipped disc fell under. Lets keep them around for the long run Thomas C. 4/22/2013
June 23 2013
June 23 2013
At the Peter Paul and Mary(in spirit) show soooo awsome loving it very peaceful vibes some protest songs activism love love love and puff the dragon thanks so much for the tickets you guys are groovy thank-you.Tom Mantello June 14 2013
Just picked up some good reggae vinyls! Great store! Marc Castelli May 11 2013
So I just went for a first-time visit to Mr. Cheapos...I love it!! I'm so glad that Long Island still has a record store with a huge variety of music! Shelley Ourian February 21 2013
Thank you for helping me out with the Snow Storm. A local merchant who helps the community - Thanks David Haft February 10 2013
Cheapo has great selection at cool prices. Jerry Miller January 29 2013
Recently found a fabulous collection of sixties folk music, plus an autographed double CD by Janis Ian at fab prices.
Hurry down to Mr. Cheapo's before it is too late, and check back every week or so, cause he keeps getting stufff in. Raymond Carrol January 28 2013